Mister Softee
If you're cruising down Bayshore Road in Villas, NJ, and you catch a whiff of sweet nostalgia in the air—chances are, you’re close to Mister Softee. Tucked away at 1890 Bayshore Rd, this cozy spot isn't just another ice cream joint. It's a local icon, blending old-school charm with the kind of comfort food that instantly lifts your mood.
The first thing you’ll notice? That signature ice cream truck-style vibe. It hits you with a wave of childhood memories before you even step through the door. And once you’re inside, it’s like being welcomed into a sweet-lover’s dream. From creamy soft serves to milkshakes that are thick enough to challenge your straw, Mister Softee keeps it classic—but never boring.
What really makes this place stand out is the way it treats the simple things like royalty. The cones are always crisp, the flavors hit just right, and there’s this laid-back, “hang out as long as you want” atmosphere. Whether you’re rolling in with kids after a beach day or sneaking in solo for a late-night sugar fix, it feels like everyone’s welcome here.
And yes, while the ice cream steals the spotlight, don’t sleep on their sundaes or floats. They’re the kind of indulgence that has you coming back for “just one more.” People around town don’t just visit Mister Softee—they talk about it, recommend it, and make it a tradition.
No matter the season, there's something special about hearing that familiar jingle outside or pulling into the lot for a scoop that never disappoints. Mister Softee isn’t just a stop—it’s part of the story for anyone who’s ever spent time around Villas, NJ.
Reviews
Great service and the ice cream is to die for. My associate and I thoroughly enjoyed the cappuccino chunk with heath bits. However, I was slightly disappointed that my spoon snapped 3 times.
Debarked for ice cream this peachy evening with an associate to relish some ice cream. The service had elements of great prodigiousness and the dish was stupendous. I felt as though it was just what I needed to fuel me for my night of gambling, skipping rocks, hittin dingers and whatnot.
Great Ice Cream &Fantastic Service- even a drive up service- for patient customers who don't mind the wait, the connivence of drive up is worth waiting
Mister Softee has a STORE? Awesome! I've grown up with their classic ice cream truck riling down my street. This was, as they say, next level. According to the locals, this is the original 1950s era first store, "where it all began ". Works for me. Fellow YES Squad member Dee M and I came by on a very warm summer evening. We parked in their decent sized private lot, then headed inside. The space is bright and clean. One area is lined by rows of ice cream cases (they sell scoops too!), behind which are very cheerful employees abandon rows of soft serve machines, toppings, work counters, and, above, giant painted menus. We ordered - I got delicious soft serve vanilla & chocolate ice cream on a cone. Dee got a divine "classic" sundae with coffee ice cream, chocolate syrup, wet walnuts and whipped cream. We sat in a nearby booth made of curved, laminated wood, ate, then waddled back to our car, happy. Definitely a place to go next time I'm down the shore. PS - there's a drive through window, too.
So good! Best icecream place EVER. I wish there was a live and working truck tracker app for nj cape may area :( But I'll take mister softees milkshakes over any other place :D